Pages

Friday, October 5, 2007

Reasons leading to Conclusion

My little sister graduated from high school in May, but she had been nagging me to buy her a brand new car for her grad gift since January. So when she approached me with this idea, I asked her if she were planning to work to contribute her share. She said no. Hm.. I asked her why she needed a car to which she replied, "I don't want to catch the bus to school." Laziness...How are you going to pay for your tuition? I asked. Dad is what she said.

She didn't give me a good enough answers to warrant me getting that car for her. I denied her request with an advice. I told her that had she first explained to me why she needed a car per good reason and impressed on me a flash of willingness to work to contribute to this car (sense of responsibility) before finally asking for it, I would probably have considered it much more. So she did it. To our parents. She got her car, but she still hasn't tried to get a job.

2 comments:

  1. As I said in class, there is a wonderful example of the subjunctive mood in Jude's post:

    So when she approached me with this idea, I asked her if she were planning to work to contribute her share.

    Remember that the subjunctive expresses something wished for, imagined. Another example:

    If I were Santa Claus, I'd give everyone books at Christmas.

    The subjunctive is on grammar's endangered species list, so try to keep it alive by using it :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. The Keables Guide (see link in the right-hand column of this page) has a good explanation of the subjunctive verb:

    Use the subjunctive mood for wishes and conditions contrary to fact:

    WRONG: If I was rich, I wouldn't be here.
    RIGHT: If I were rich, I wouldn't be here.

    WRONG: I wish she was here.
    RIGHT: I wish she were here.

    WRONG: I recommend that he leaves.
    RIGHT: I recommend that he leave.

    WRONG: I move that the meeting is adjourned.
    RIGHT: I move that the meeting be adjourned.

    Grammar Tips: Verbs have three moods:

    INDICATIVE (STATEMENTS OF FACT): I shut the door.
    IMPERATIVE (COMMANDS): Shut the door.
    SUBJUNCTIVE: I wish I had shut the door.

    People seldom use the subjunctive mood nowadays except in three situations:

    (1) if clauses expressing conditions contrary to fact;

    (2) that clauses following verbs like wish, ask, recommend and urge;

    (3) a few familiar expressions ("be that as it may"; "to whom it may concern").

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.